6 min read

Am I responsible for making it right with my terminally-ill mom?

A complicated past is colliding with the pressures of achieving "closure," if such a thing is possible.
The Tell Your Cat I Said... logo, featuring a pouncing black cat with big eyes.
Credit: rommy torrico

Dear s.e.,

My mom is terminally ill with breast cancer. Chemo drugs have kept her quality of life high for a long time, but it’s finally starting to look like we’re coming to the end of her road. I’ve spent a lot of my adult life in all kinds of therapy, but family therapy isn’t one that my next of kin have wanted to participate in. This sometimes makes me feel like we’re talking at odds to each other, or at least like we might not be speaking the same language more often than not.

My mom did the best she could parenting me, but she came from a background with more trauma than love and it reflected in how she treated me. She was often angry and sometimes abusive, and I’ve had to unlearn a lot on my own. My mom has offered a blanket apology for those behaviors and tells me all the time that she “wants to have the hard conversations” with me while she still can about things like how she parented me growing up, but the day rarely comes that we actually do talk about the hard things—or if we do, my therapized self comes into conflict with her avoidance and our directly conflicting memories.

How the hell do I handle this? Do I just resign myself to not having these conversations and getting “closure”—whatever the hell that means anyways—before she dies? Do I keep forcing the issue? Or do I just accept that maybe my parents can’t provide everything for me and this is a place where I have to emotionally self-resource, much like I did through childhood?

—End of the Road

Hey there, End of the Road,

I'm sorry to hear about your mother; it sounds like you have had a complicated relationship and haven't really had a chance to reckon with that honestly and openly together, and that's a hard thing to sit with while you're facing the end of her life. It's also really tough to experience what for lack of a better word I would call a mismatch of emotional growth and maturity. You've been showing up and doing the work in therapy to care for yourself and learn to be a better human, and she has not, which can feel acutely frustrating when you feel time running out.

One thing I will say up front: You do not owe her, or anyone else, including yourself, anything, and that includes chasing some kind of myth of "closure," a word people love to throw around that I find functionally meaningless. This isn't a doorway where there's a bright line of open or closed, done or left lingering. It's impossible to know what "closure" might look like when you're on this side of a transition like this. It's also very easy to beat yourself up now, and later, for choices you are, or aren't, making.

People will say that you are going to regret it if you don't give your mother peace at the end of her life, but where's the judgement of your mother for failing to give you peace?

Remember that she, too, has made her choices and also needs to live with them and decide what actions she wants to take to address the harm she caused. And you already know this, but "a blanket apology" isn't what's needed here. A meaningful apology expresses understanding and regret. Does she know which "behaviors" are at issue here? Does she understand the legacy she's left you with, and the amount of unlearning and growth you've had to do? Is she willing to actually acknowledge and engage with your lived experience of your relationship, not just what she imagines is your shared experience? Because if the answer to any of these is "no," then she is not, in fact, ready to have the hard conversations and it takes two people to have those conversations.

We live in a culture where there's a lot of pressure to "reconcile" and "set aside differences" at the end of people's lives, usually in the context of the wronged person being responsible for both of these things. People will say that you are going to regret it if you don't give your mother peace at the end of her life, but where's the judgement of your mother for failing to give you peace?

Your parents owed you a childhood filled with love, care, and support. It sounds like you didn't get that. Being forced to "self-resource" is unjust, and it also highlights the ways in which those of us who have experienced harm in our childhoods try to convince ourselves that somehow we are at fault and responsible for fixing it. We shouldn't have to do it and we should say that.

That brings me to the probably ultimately challenging and unfulfilling thing about the answer to this question, and I think you know this already in your heart: Handling this may, in fact, require accepting the fact that you're probably not going to have the conversation you need to have and deserve. Your mother may never fully understand the harm she caused or be willing to talk about it with you. With time, growth, and self-reflection, some people do become capable of having these conversations, but it sounds like your mother is running out of all three and didn't take advantage of them when she had the chance.

I think here of the wisdom of my colleague at The Flytrap, Andrea Grimes, when she responded to a letter writer agonizing over her MAGA granny. What outcome do you want here? She had some guiding questions, including:

If no apology is forthcoming, can you be at peace with yourself for asking for one, anyway?...If you're coming to this out of anything other than a desire to seek peace for yourself because you just can't rest unless you give [your mom] the chance to do right, I would urge you to do more work in therapy before reaching out...Can you think of yourself as brave, forgiving, and open-hearted for giving her this one last chance to do the right thing?...Think hard about what you need to hear and how likely you are to hear it. Can you accept an imperfect apology?

These are things to turn over in your own head and also to bring to therapy, because a good therapist keeps us honest and help you confront these questions. If your ideal outcome is a heartfelt, meaningful series of conversations where your mother takes ownership of her life and choices, and you're going to feel unfulfilled if that doesn't happen, that may be a sign that pushing further on this is not going to benefit you.

I do think there's a case for trying, one more time, to have this conversation, to say "you've said in the past that you'd like to really sit down and have an authentic conversation about my childhood, about the way you treated me. I do feel like every time we try to have this conversation, you deny my experience and offer a really evasive and vague 'general apology' without seeming to understand what you are apologizing for. I am willing to try, one final time, to have this conversation with you, if you are willing to genuinely engage with me."

It would seem like your mother is probably...not going to be convinced to have this conversation with a therapist or other facilitator in the room, which is unfortunate, since it is pretty clear that the two of you on your own just can't align enough to really have this talk. That person could help you both stay regulated, could push at your mother's denial and, frankly, gaslighting, could also help you articulate what you are trying to say and make sure you feel heard. They can also help you process how that conversation goes and decide what, if any, next steps you want to take.

It's worth asking if a facilitator is an option, and it's also reasonable to make it a dealbreaker: "In the past this conversation has not gone well and it often feels like we talk at cross-purposes. I would like to bring in someone to facilitate it so we can really do this work together."

Maybe she says no to this. And maybe that tells you all you need to know.

Tell your mother I said...

If you want to go to your grave without truly acknowledging your legacy, that's your choice, and I think you're going to regret it!